Recruiting migrant workers - Why half of them are gone within six years, and what an employer brand changes about that

  • news

In most blue collar sectors, recruiting migrant workers is no longer an emergency measure. It is part of workforce planning. The Dutch labour market simply does not produce enough people for logistics, construction, engineering and food production, so employers look to Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Greece and increasingly to countries outside the EU, such as Georgia and the Western Balkans.

And then it tends to go wrong in the same way. People arrive, production runs again, and two years later a large part of that group has gone. Not to the competitor down the road, but back home or to an employer who had their act together. That is not recruitment, that is maintaining a revolving door. This piece is about doing it differently, and about why most of the work starts after someone says yes.

Why does recruiting migrant workers start with a problem, not with a country?

The first question is never which country. The first question is which problem you are actually solving. Are your vacancies not filling? Or are they filling, but nobody stays? Are you attracting the wrong people? Or is the real bottleneck that six weeks pass between application and first working day, and the good candidates drop out along the way?

That distinction decides everything. International recruitment is expensive and slow. If your problem is first-year turnover, you do not fix it by opening the intake tap further. You just widen the leak.

So agree up front which number has to move. How many people come in per month, how many are still there after nine months, what is your lead time, what does a departure cost in training time and agency margin? A baseline takes two weeks and decides, afterwards, whether you have a campaign that demonstrably did something or one everyone has an opinion about. It helps internally too: a board wants to see a number.

How many labour migrants actually work in the Netherlands?

Nobody knows exactly, and that in itself says something. In 2026 Statistics Netherlands (CBS) put the counts side by side in its publication on attitudes towards labour migrants and arrived at wildly different outcomes depending on the definition. According to the registers, at the end of 2023 almost 910 thousand people were working here who did not hold Dutch nationality when they immigrated. The Migrant Monitor, which also counts people not registered with a municipality, came to 1.6 million for the same period. Research by SEO Economisch Onderzoek, using a stricter definition, counted almost 700 thousand labour migrants in 2023.

The practical lesson: if a whole country cannot count who is working and for how long, your organisation probably cannot either. Plenty of companies know how many agency workers are on site today, and have no idea how many of last year’s international intake are still there.

Why does half of them leave again, and what does that say about your recruitment?

The Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency (PBL) tracked 61,500 EU labour migrants who settled in the rural Netherlands between 2011 and 2017. Half had disappeared from municipal registration within six years. The other half were still there.

The difference between those two groups is the interesting part. Those who left had, on arrival, more often a low household income, more often worked through a temp agency and more often shared a home. Among those who stayed, that picture shifted: agency work fell from 39 to 23 percent, shared housing from 43 to 31 percent, low household income from 59 to 42 percent. People did not stay out of attachment to the village. They stayed because their position improved.

Read that as recruitment information. On arrival, 47 percent started through a temp agency, 64 percent shared a home and 68 percent came without a partner. If you can show what it looks like a year later, a permanent contract, your own place, a certificate, a step up, you are saying something almost no competitor says. And if you cannot deliver it, do not promise it.

What can Germany teach us about recruiting across the border?

Since 2016 Germany has had the Westbalkanregelung: people from Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Kosovo, North Macedonia, Montenegro and Serbia can take a job there without a qualification requirement. On 16 October 2026 the Bundesagentur für Arbeit published the results. Around 546,000 people from those countries now hold insured employment in Germany, 170,000 more than five years ago. And although the scheme demands no formal qualification, 53 percent of them work at skilled level or above, almost half of those in a recognised shortage occupation: mainly construction, transport and logistics, hospitality and care.

That takes apart the idea that a low-threshold route only produces unskilled intake. What people end up doing is not determined by the permit they enter on, but by what the employer does with them afterwards. The annual quota of 50,000 has proved too tight, the German government wants to halve it from January 2027, and the Bundesagentur is arguing to keep it as it is.

Which brings a second lesson: policy changes. If your strategy leans on a single route that may halve next year, you have a pipeline with a tap somebody else controls.

What should you promise, and what should you not?

An employee value proposition for international recruitment rests on the same three pillars as any other: what the outside world says about you, what your own people say, and what the market offers. Only the content shifts. The difference rarely sits in the hourly wage, often fixed in a collective agreement. It sits in housing, in the distance between bed and workplace, in travel costs home, in whether someone moves out of the agency construction after a year, and in whether there are Dutch lessons and who pays.

That is exactly why employer branding here is not product marketing. You take a job home with you, and in international recruitment literally so: you move for it, you sleep in housing your employer arranges, you see your family less. A promise that turns out to be a bunk bed in a holiday park is common knowledge in the group chats back home within two weeks. Not through a review site, through people.

An honest picture therefore also works as a filter. If the work is in a freezer, show the freezer. The people who cannot handle it drop out, and that is a gain. Every candidate who leaves on day four cost you a flight, a week of training and the patience of the team.

Where do work permits belong in your candidate story?

For EU countries such as Poland, Romania, Bulgaria and Greece, free movement of workers applies and no work permit is needed. For countries outside it, Georgia for example, it runs through a work permit or a combined residence and work permit, including a labour market test by the Dutch UWV. That takes time and the outcome is not guaranteed.

Most employers treat this as legal background noise. Missed opportunity. For the candidate it is the main question: can I come, for how long, what if I want to change jobs, can my partner join me? Explain that on a candidate page in their own language, with a realistic lead time, and you win trust on the one point where everyone else stays vague.

Also look at who is already here: status holders allowed to work, partners of knowledge migrants, people who have worked through an agency for years and would like something permanent. In our work for VluchtelingenWerk we saw how large that group is and how badly employers connect to it. Before booking a recruitment trip to Tbilisi, it pays to look at who is ready within fifty kilometres.

Who tells that story most credibly?

Your own people. A Polish forklift driver who has worked for you for three years and explains in his own language what he earns and where he lives is more convincing than any campaign you can buy. And harder to argue with, because he stands on the floor the candidate is about to join.

AI helps enormously with scale: subtitles and versions in six languages, regional variants, quick tests of what lands where. Not with the substance. Why fake someone synthetically when you could simply film them? For Picnic we worked on employer branding in logistics, where intake at scale and internal progression through the Picnic Academy sit side by side. That is the point: in international recruitment, hiring and keeping are not two projects but one.

How does MonFri approach this?

We start with your problem and the numbers underneath it. Is the intake stuck, or is it walking out? Then we look at the three pillars: what the outside world says about you, what your own international employees say, and what competitors for the same people offer. Only then do we decide whether the answer is a campaign, a better candidate page in three languages, a shorter lead time, or onboarding that survives the first year.

Want to think this through for your sector? Have a look at our services, read International recruitment and Recruiting staff abroad, or call us on 020 23 38 587. You can also email hi@mon-fri.com.