Recruiting career switchers - Let them try the work before they apply
- news
Engineering has a sum that does not add up. There are more technical vacancies than there are technicians, and no wave of graduates is coming to close that gap any time soon. Recruiting career switchers is no longer a side route, it is one of the few places where real headroom is left. And yet it is moving the wrong way. The TechBarometer by Dutch technical training provider ROVC found in late 2025 that only 25 percent of technical employers actively target career switchers, down from 44 percent two years earlier.
It is not the people who are the problem. An earlier edition of the same study, among 1,000 potential career switchers, found that 55 percent considered engineering an attractive sector to work in and 60 percent had positive associations with the trade. The interest is there. What is missing is a route from that interest to a first day on the job.
Why does recruiting career switchers not start with a job ad?
A job ad is a terminus. It assumes someone already knows what the work involves, already believes they can do it, and only needs to decide where to apply. For an experienced technician that holds. For someone currently working in hospitality or healthcare, none of it holds.
The numbers point straight at the breaking point. In the TechBarometer, 58 percent of potential career switchers said they simply did not know where to start, and 56 percent found the retraining schemes and subsidies unclear. That is not a motivation problem, it is an information problem. ROVC director John Huizing noted that no chain exists linking enthusiasm, training and an actual job, which leaves a switcher with very little to hold on to.
Not every problem is a campaign. Sometimes the answer is a page in plain language about what the step costs, how long it takes and who pays for it.
What stops people who already find engineering appealing?
This is where the real barrier sits, and it is psychological. In the same study, 88 percent said business would grind to a halt without technicians and 87 percent saw engineering as genuine craftsmanship. Respect is not the issue. Yet 55 percent also felt a technical job did not suit them, 32 percent thought it was physically too demanding, and 44 percent said they wished they were handy enough for a technical trade.
People reject themselves before anyone else gets the chance. And they do it unevenly: 14 percent of women seriously considered a switch, against 25 percent of men. Every piece of communication that opens with “are you the technician we are looking for” confirms exactly the picture that makes those 55 percent walk away.
So the problem is not visibility. It is whether people believe this work is also meant for them.
What changes when you let people experience the work first?
The assumption disappears. A day on site, an evening in the workshop, a short trial module or a film following a technician through their day does something no promise can: it replaces a hunch with an experience. Someone who gets home thinking “I could do this” is a different candidate from someone who hopes so.
This is one of the best researched principles in recruitment. The meta-analysis by Jean Phillips in the Academy of Management Journal in 1998, covering forty studies, showed that realistic job previews are associated with lower voluntary turnover, lower drop-out during the recruitment process and higher performance.
Research by Earnest, Allen and Landis in Personnel Psychology in 2011 showed why it works: candidates come to see the organisation as more honest. That is the whole mechanism. A hesitant career switcher is not buying a promise, they are buying the feeling that nobody is selling them a story.
Is an honest picture bad for your application numbers?
In the short term, sometimes. Early shifts, dirty hands and working outside in February will make people drop out. That feels like a loss, especially if you are judged on application volume.
But that is the point. An employer brand is a magnet and a filter at the same time. Anyone who drops out after a day on site would otherwise have left after three months, with a failed onboarding behind them and a vacancy open again. With career switchers that weighs heavier, because you invest in training them before they become productive.
A job also comes home with you. Moving from healthcare into engineering changes your rhythm, your colleagues and what you talk about at the dinner table. That is a family decision, not an impulse purchase.
What does a diploma requirement actually cost you?
More than you think. The TechBarometer found that 34 percent of technical companies treat a vocational diploma as a hard requirement, while 52 percent of employers in the same study said they would prefer a candidate who can safely carry out a set of tasks over someone holding that diploma. The first sits in the job profile, the second sits in the workshop manager’s head.
Internationally the pattern is well documented. The Skills-Based Hiring study by the Burning Glass Institute and Harvard Business School in 2024 looked at employers who dropped their degree requirements and found that this changed the actual outcome in fewer than one in seven hundred hires. Around 45 percent of the companies studied changed the wording only, not the behaviour.
Among the companies that did follow through, something worth noting happened. They increased the share of people hired without a degree in those roles by nearly 20 percent, and those people stayed at a rate 10 percentage points higher than their degree-holding colleagues. Dropping a requirement from the text is easy. Dropping it from the selection is where the difference is made.
What has to be right internally before the first career switcher arrives?
An employee value proposition rests on three pillars: what the outside world says about you, what your own people say, and what the market offers. For career switchers the middle pillar decides everything. The technician with twenty years of experience who gets a beginner alongside them determines whether this intake succeeds.
The TechBarometer found that 56 percent of companies have an onboarding programme, often combined with internal training, coaching or a buddy system. The question is not whether it exists, but whether experienced colleagues see it as part of their job or as a burden on top of their own schedule.
Recruiting here is also recruiting to retain. For a career switcher the candidate journey only ends after a year. Get those twelve months right and you are rewarded with the most credible ambassadors you will ever have: people who made the switch themselves and know exactly what the next hesitant candidate needs to hear.
How do you measure whether recruiting career switchers actually works?
By agreeing in advance which number has to move. Not application volume, because with an honest story that is a poor gauge. Rather: how many people without a technical background join an orientation session, how many of them move on to an interview, how long a vacancy stays open, and how many of that intake are still there after twelve months.
A baseline measurement costs very little. Do you know how many candidates you turned down last year purely for lacking a diploma? That single number is often enough to open the internal conversation, and you need that conversation. Without support on the shop floor and in HR, career switching becomes a pilot that quietly dies.
Measuring also shows what not to do. Sometimes the problem is not at the front end at all, but in a six-week application process or a careers page in which no career switcher recognises themselves.
How does MonFri approach recruiting career switchers?
We start with the problem, not with the instrument. Are vacancies failing to fill, or filling with the wrong people? Is the intake leaving within the first year? Does the market know you as an employer at all? That determines whether we end up with a campaign, a better careers platform, content that stays visible all year, or an orientation programme where people see the work before they apply.
Then we collect the story where it actually lives: on the shop floor. For Hanab, part of VolkerWessels, we built the employer brand around the people doing the work, with imagery and stories from the sites themselves. That is also where we draw the line on AI: excellent for variants, testing and speed, but why fabricate a person you could simply film. A career switcher recognises a real story, and a made-up one just as quickly.
Want to know where your real bottleneck sits? Take a look at our services, call 020 23 38 587 or email hi@mon-fri.com. For more on recruitment in engineering, read recruiting technicians or employer branding for manufacturing.